Dear Doctor Pokorny,
My buddies and I use the classic game Rock, Paper, Scissor to settle everything. You know…who gets to chase the best looking bridesmaid or who has to clean our dorm’s kitchen. It’s gotten to the point where we have begun calling each other by their favorite play – like my friend Dwayne – we call him “The Rock.” My name is Ed so of course people call me “Scissorhands” – which was only funny the first time.
Ok, so here’s my problem – we need a new way of deciding things. Is there another game we can play to make small and large decisions in our lives? I mean – just by reading this letter you should be able to tell that there’s no way we reason our way to a correct decision.
Thanks and if you answer my question I’ll get you a free pizza from the place I work – if you live in Scuttlebutt, Connecticut. If you don’t live in Scuttlebutt, I’ll deliver the pizza myself but only if you’re within, like, uh, twenty miles of town. That’s as far as I can get in a half hour, you know what I mean?
Edward – Scuttlebutt, CT
Edward-
Have you ever tried flipping a coin?! Of course, a guy like you probably doesn’t have any money.
Despite the ridiculous nature of your question, I do have a soft spot for the game that aided me with the tough choices of childhood. As my classmates and I advanced through the grades we added one rule to the game each year until junior high when we started making decisions with our hormones. Here are the adjustments that made Paper, Rock, Scissors into something a bit more intriguing.
1st Grade-
KARATE CHOP- Bring our fist down towards the palm and at the last second open the side of your play hand to the palm / Yell, “Hi-ya!”
WHAT IT BEATS- Nothing really…except your crayons.
WHAT BEATS IT- Everything. This is just a play for the slow kids who didn’t know how the game worked. The kids in the know would encourage the stooge to karate chop – the stooge would get excited and do the best, loudest, most dynamic karate chop he could – then everyone would tell him he lost.
RESULTS- Lots of, “Go back to Kindergarten, you tourist!”
2nd Grade
SIMULTANEOUS PLAY- Bring your play hand down on your open palm at the SAME TIME!
RESULTS- Some kid in Akron, Ohio, was finally able to beat Sammy “the Sloth” Malone. Once Sammy was barred from playing a full three seconds after the first player, his career as a professional Rock, Paper, Scissors player went downhill. He now lives in Chicago.
3rd Grade
FISH- Bring play hand down on palm and open it at the last second / instead of letting the hand rest (that would be paper) flop it around.
WHAT IT BEATS- Nothing.
WHAT IT LOSES TO- Nothing. Make this play over and over again to drive your friends to distraction. Once they get frustrated call them a “big baby.” Laugh…repeat.
RESULT- A harmless game of Rock, Paper, Scissors would often be set aside for Fist, Face, Bloody Nose.
4th Grade
ATOMIC BOMB - Shaping hand hits palm with the back of the wrist / all fingers on the playing hand go up into the air. Adding a “BOOM” afterward makes your point and then rubs it in.
WHAT IT BEATS- Atomic Bomb beats Rock, Paper, Scissors, Fish.
WHAT IT LOSES TO- Nothing…at least not yet.
FALLOUT- When Rock, Paper, Scissors became Rock, Paper, Scissors, Atomic Bomb, the game became nearly unplayable. Slow witted kids would still try the occasional Scissor only to have it blown to bits buy the Atomic Bomb. The United Nations finally stepped in and issued a non-binding resolution number #0002B, which banned the use of the Atomic Bomb play. It was summarily ignored.
5th Grade
FALLOUT SHELTER- Bring play fist toward open palm / just before the fist hits the palm bend wrist forward and back / the fist should fly right past the palm.
WHAT IT BEATS- Only Atomic Bomb.
WHAT IT LOSES TO- Rock, Paper, Scissors, Karate Chop, Fish
RESULT- With atomic weapons threatening to destroy Rock, Paper, Scissors, our class decided to develop the Fallout Shelter play. It was a rousing success.
6th Grade
BEST TWO OUT OF THREE- You must count aloud to three then say, “Shoot.” Something as important as who gets the last donut cannot be left to a single play. Allegations of cheating and delayed selection can tear apart friendships and destroy lives. The Best Two Out of Three development allowed each party to more closely watch the other for fraud.
RESULT- People still cheat only now it takes longer to play Rock, Paper, Scissors.
Ed, Just try a Magic Eight Ball Keychain.
Sincerely, Dr. Pokorny